Early in my career, IBM decided to go into the analytical instrument business. They spent eight hundred million dollars and seven years of my life chasing this dream. I probably learned more from their failure than if the business had succeeded. To this date, I am in touch with many of my colleagues who also endured this experience. It was our Vietnam. What a great bunch of guys these were. Excellent employees are motivated by challenge and overcoming challenges is what we lost our milk teeth doing. The importance of working with excellent people is a valuable lesson.
One of the primary reasons for this business failure was the company's lack of market knowledge. It shouldn't have taken long to discover that typewriter salesmen cannot sell analytical instruments. Someone should also have told these struggling salesmen that decision makers in this market wear white lab coats and are thereby recognizable in the hall. Knowing the market is basic to any sales effort and was another lesson in point.
The third lesson I learned in working with a failed business is that unrealistic sales goals will kill you. Each year the president of the division set new sales goals by growing the unmet sales goals of the past year. An unfulfilled goal was expanded by twenty percent for seven years, right up until the big blue sign on the front lawn came down. Actual sales was a number not even to be found on the computer.
Compounding this problem, was the fact that expenses were increased based upon unrealized revenue. This is why eight hundred million dollars had dissappeared before the game was called. When your expense line is greater than revenue, there is a problem. Real money flowed out while fantasy money flowed in. Realistic goals would have helped in the beginning. There was little excuse for not using actual sales numbers as a basis for expenditures later on.
Years have passed. Other companies have gone down the same track, but I have known the pitfalls. I now start screaming whenever the tendency to fail to appreciate the value of challenge to employees surfaces. Before going into any business, I spend lots of time and resources knowing the market, saving the company lots of time and resources later on. I know that only actual accomplishments are good enough for setting goals, thereby allowing expenses to grow at a rate less than sales.
The value of experience is not to be under rated.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment